Amy Winehouse and Billie Holiday

I have an account over at blip.fm, which has been described as Twitter for music.  I like it, but then again I like most music services that introduce me to music that other people like and not necessarily the music that some program director somewhere likes or some company in cahoots with the music industry is trying to sell me.  To me, this is the flaw of last.fm’s radio stations and Apple’s new Genius feature in the latest version of iTunes.

One of the songs that I have heard is the demo version of a song by Amy Winehouse called ‘Love Is A Losing Game.’  Like a lot of people I have only heard a couple of Amy Winehouse songs and I am more familiar with her rather obvious self destruction that some people seem to relish in documenting on a weekly (if not almost daily) basis.  Her voice in the song is powerful but flawed, filled with a tragic beauty that I would have caught even if I had no idea who was singing.
It reminds me so much of the later days of Billie Holiday that it is eerie.  There are other recent singers who have been compared to Lady Day.  Norah Jones, Madeleine Peyroux and Diana Krall immediately come to mind, but none of them have this sense of tragic inevitability in their voices that Winehouse brings.
Here is a clip of Billie Holiday and Lester Young singing the song ‘Fine and Mellow’ that I was thinking of when I heard ‘Love Is A Losing Game.’  

It would be really easy to just say “Poor girl, I hope somebody helps her”, but I really think that we are seeing the last chapters of her story and while she may have some people around her who want to help her get better and stronger, I think that there are just as many (if no more) people around her who want to see her fail and fall. There is a lot bigger potential for making money off of the tragedy of Amy Winehouse’s life if she isn’t around to get better. Expect several tabloid shows to cover her death for weeks if not months with a lot tongue clucking and fake headshaking accompanied with the phrase “so young” being thrown around a lot.

A few posthumous albums later and Amy Winehouse will be forgotten as anything more than a punchline to jokes that will never make it on late night talk shows. Unfortunately for her, she will never gain the pop culture longevity of Billie Holiday, even though there will be a lot of similarities between them.


Posted

in

by